2026-11-11 22:25 UTC
This is an issue for me in two provinces.
The first is in sorting out interpersonal conflicts. I know if I feel my colleague (partner, rival, fellow participant) is not comprehending my side of the matter, is not arguing in good faith, or is not taking the issue seriously, then I’ll get heated and my capacity to think straight will diminish. I also assume other people experience the same phenomenon.
And the second is in sorting out philosophical positions. In my experience, live debate is about debate tactics, appeals to emotion, obfuscation, argument schemes intended to disorient the opponent. In the heyday of the new atheism movement, Dawkins often discussed commonly used toxic rhetorical devices used by apologists. (the gish gallop, mott and bailey, and so on.)
And years later we saw the same sort of debate methods used notoriously by Charlie Kirk, who seemed to seek to debate unskilled college students in order to give his positions the illusion of legitimacy, initially about xenophobic MAGA ideology but later pro-Israel / anti-Palestine politics.
So, I’ve learned, the oral dialectic is not great for sorting out the truth. A text argument allows me to distill the point being made and see where that fits in the philosophical model (as I understand it). Dan McClellan has a habit of finding an argument, steel-manning it to assume the best meaning by the arguer and then discussing the biblical scholarship that intersects with that position.
Written positions also allow the argument to be checked for inconsistencies, so it’s actually a good thing when demagogues author an ill-conceived book justifying their positions. Less so when they have AI write it for them.
Replies (0)
No replies.